In “Guidelines and additional provisions for the PhD Programmes at VID Specialized University”, the following is stated about the final evaluation:
The doctoral student is offered a final evaluation 2-3 months before the thesis is expected to be submitted, in the form of a final seminar, alternatively a final reading, with one (1) evaluator.
Based on a draft of the thesis text, the student must be given an assessment of an advisory nature for the remaining work on the thesis. The main supervisor, in consultation with the doctoral student, is responsible for arranging the final evaluation. The evaluator of the final evaluation cannot be a member of the committee for assessment of the PhD thesis.
Purpose
The main purpose is an evaluation of the scientific quality of the thesis when it is close to completion (so-called 90% evaluation).
The final evaluation is in the form of a final seminar or a final reading.
A final seminar is an oral assessment of the thesis which engages the candidate in a critical dialogue about elements in the thesis that must be addressed to be able to complete and submit it for formal assessment.
A final seminar can either be an
- open digital, physical or hybrid seminar that is announced on VID's websites der
or a
- closed digital, physical or hybrid seminar with invited participants
A final reading is a written assessment of the draft of the dissertation, giving advice on the remaining work. It should make clear to the student what the current status of the dissertation is and the work required to be able to complete it and submit it for formal assessment.
A final reading consists of:
- Written feedback in the thesis text as well as an overall note that is sent to the student, principal supervisor and center manager.
The main supervisor clarifies with the PhD student whether the person concerned wishes to have a final evaluation in the form of a final reading, in accordance with the provision in VID's supplementary guidelines and regulations.
Speak to your main supervisor if you wish to complete a final evaluation of your thesis.